Watched a full length documentary called Religulous, ( probably merging of religion and ridiculous) an American production. The narrator is a stand up comedian called Bill Maher; yeah they can take a stand on anything. America for all that it stands and doesn't stand for is a very open society, the views expressed in public, would bring a nation like India to a bloody civil war. They have varied levels leading to and away from religion, the theist and the atheist being the closest and the farthest respectively. American society has and had quite a handful of atheists, this particular sect being treated like the carrier of some deadly disease by the majority of the very religious and church going Americans. Too many despicable and downright crass moral and social stigmas are attributed to the completely ungodly creatures, namely the atheists.
This documentary is no different from the huge amount of sound and fury spewing out of the land of plenty, time and again. Any talk,book,movie,documentary, audio or video about or against religion is widely followed and marketed; it always scores high. Religulous is no different, the narrator essays a silky smooth barging into the private lairs of some rich and powerful religious leaders or representatives to defy everything that religion stands for and does. He throws question, levels veiled accusations, scorches, stumps, bruises,punches and laughs at the pot bellied, Armani suited 'scholars'. They evidently are playing to the camera, some making it look real, others fumbling and stuttering, maybe praying that this gets over soon. The whole episode is a series of short interviews aimed at poking fun at the concept, misinterpretation and general shortcomings of religions all over the world.
Maher knows his onions, or is rather well prepared for the roasting of his victims, while keeping the proceedings light hearted and jovial. But the point is that inspite of making severe dents into the foundation of religion, like pointing to the glaring glitches in history(usual),linking of private wealth of preachers to blind faith(hackneyed) to rationalizing miracles to every day phenomena(clever), the documentary fails where all American tirades against religion fail, its adversity to atheist way. We, in India look at religion as either true or false, not the Americans, a vehement no to religion is still unacceptable to them. The narrator, like all other rationalists from America, relies on the seed of doubt to express his and all fellow brothers and sisters inability to see what religion is up to. They conveniently call themselves agnostics, a fancy term for the doubting Thomases. By this they mean that they are unsure, 'by doubting you are being rational' booms Maher. nah! you aren't being rational, you are trying to escape the twin dilemma of becoming a social outcast and a futureless,rootless flying twig. There are a lot of unmentionable attributes strangely given to the atheists, the veracity of the same though cannot be vouched by yours truly. 'Atheists do not vote, do drugs, blah blah blah'...went on an American i personally know, himself an agnostic.
i remember the sensible statement from another agnostic American, Richard Dawkins, 'physical science has a long way to go before it unearths the mystery of the all that is there around us, hence it is safe to say that all arguments for or against religion are not final, both are true and untrue at the same time'. That is solid ground for the agnostics, this yes and no, easy to adopt and say 'i doubt', instead of saying 'i deny' and get lynched. This view does not change anything, but it is better than a 'yes i believe so bring out the nuclear warheads'. Peace and human progress shall be achieved when assorted no-brainers like of 'doubts', 'beliefs', 'service', 'rituals', 'miracles','punishment', 'rewards in heaven', etc etc are totally and thoroughly washed down from our collective conscience. With religion around us, its a 'miracle' to live another day. Without it, there will be heaven without death. Another miracle!